2018 The Middle East Legal Awards
 
Judging Process


The panel of judges is made up of senior Middle East-based in-house lawyers and other leading figures from within the business community. Legal Week will assign categories to be judged by the panel, in consultation with the chair of the judging panel and the ACC. Each category is judged by at least four judges.

Once all the entries have been submitted, the Legal Week editorial team will produce a shortlist of up to a maximum of nine entries per category. Before the shortlist is announced, the chair of the judging panel will be consulted in order to ensure that the process is robust. The chair of the panel will have the opportunity to review all the rejected entries and substitute them with existing entries.

Prior to the judging day, the judges are requested to identify their first and second choices, with a brief reason for their first choice. Thereafter, the judges meet in person to debate the merits of the chosen entries and to confirm the winning entry. The process to be adopted is the choice of chair of the judging panel. In cases where a consensus is not reached, the chair of the panel has the final say. The decision of the panel is final and details of the deliberations will remain confidential.

Prospective judges with an interest, either personally, by association as part of a team or a member thereof, are not eligible to fulfil a judging role for that award category.